(508) 428-6936

  • Home
  • Menu
  • Daily Dinners
  • Catering
  • Locations
  • More
    • Home
    • Menu
    • Daily Dinners
    • Catering
    • Locations

(508) 428-6936


  • Home
  • Menu
  • Daily Dinners
  • Catering
  • Locations
Historic Cotuit Grocery Co. decorated with pumpkins and cornstalks for fall.

Catering Menu

Appetizers

Sausage Stuffed Mushrooms

$3.50 each

button mushrooms stuffed w. italian sausage, red peppers, cracker crumbs

served on steam table trays

Stuffed Scallops

$6.95 each

stuffed w. shrimp, scallops, lobster, breadcrumbs

order hot or cold

served on steam table trays

Bruschetta Bites

$3.50 each

crostini w. tomato, basil, balsamic glaze

Ciliegine Caprese Bites

$3.50 each

skewers w. mozzarella balls, grape tomato, basil

small platter is approx. 25-30 pieces

Chicken Wings

$3.50 each

flavors: buffalo, bbq, garlic butter, honey BBQ, teriyaki, sweet chili, plain

Shrimp Cocktail

$3.50 each

cooked jumbo shrimp w. cocktail sauce

served on a platter

*please call in advance*


Soups & Gravy

By the quart

$12.99

  • chili
  • clam chowder
  • lobster bisque
  • chicken noodle
  • broccoli cheddar
  • portuguese kale
  • gravy


Hot Entrees

half pan $69.95 | full pan $139 unless priced otherwise

Veggie Lasagna

half pan serves 9-12

full pan serves 15-18

Beef Lasagna

half pan serves 9-12

full pan serves 15-18

Eggplant Parmesan

half pan serves 9-12

full pan serves 15-18

Mac & Cheese

half pan serves 12 (if using as a side)

full pan serves 20-25 (if using as a side)

Broccoli Chicken Alfredo

half pan serves 12 (if using as a side)

full pan serves 20-25 (if using as a side)

Shepherd's Pie

half pan serves 9-12

full pan serves 15-18

American Chop Suey

half pan serves 12 (if using as a side)

full pan serves 20-25 (if using as a side)

Meatloaf

turkey or beef

half pan holds 2 full meat loaves 

full pan holds 4 full meat loaves 

each loaf has approx. 6-9 slices 

Mashed Potatoes

half pan serves 12 (if using as a side)

full pan serves 20-25 (if using as a side)

Mixed Grilled Vegtables

grilled, steamed, or roasted

half pan serves 12 (if using as a side)

full pan serves 20-25 (if using as a side)

Broccoli in Cheese Sauce

half pan serves 12 (if using as a side)

full pan serves 20-25 (if using as a side)

Chicken Pot Pie Sheet Pan

individual pies available in 6" or 12"

Roasted Turkey Breast

half pan holds approx. 1 full sliced turkey breast

full pan holds approx. 2-3 full sliced turkey breasts 

Stuffing

half pan serves 12 (if using as a side)

full pan serves 20-25 (if using as a side)

BBQ Baby Back Ribs

1/2 rack of ribs serves 1 

please allow 48-72 hr. notice 

half pan can hold approx. 4-5 half racks of ribs (or 2 1/2 full racks)

full pan can hold approx. 8-10 half racks of ribs (or 5 full racks)

BBQ Split Chickens

please allow 48-72 hr. notice 

half pan can fit approx. 4 chicken quarters

full pan can fit approx. 8 chicken quarters

BBQ Pulled Pork

please allow 48-72 hr. notice 

half pan serves 15-20

full pan serves 30-40+

BBQ Pulled Chicken

please allow 48-72 hr. notice

half pan serves 15-20

full pan serves 30-40+

Baked Beans

half pan serves 12 (if using as a side)

full pan serves 20-25 (if using as a side)

Cornbread

half pan 9 slices

full pan 18-24 slices

Pot Roast

please allow 48-72 hr. notice

half pan serves 15-20

full pan serves 30-40+

Stuffed Peppers

red and green bell peppers stuffed with rice, cheese, ground beef and marinara

half pan holds approx. 9 stuffed peppers 

full pan holds approx. 18 stuffed peppers depending on pepper size

Sausage, Peppers & Onions

half pan serves 9-12

full pan serves 18-24

Marinated Steak Tips

$32.99/lb

please allow 48-72 hr. notice


Breakfast & Bakery Platters

small platters $39.95, large platters $69.95

Pastry Platter

assorted pastries of your choice

  • croissants: almond, chocolate, plain
  • danish: apple, blueberry cheese, chocolate, spinach feta, sweet cheese 
  • muffins: banana nut, blueberry, chocolate chip, cinnamon, cranberry orange
  • scones: blueberry, cranberry orange,  cinnamon, chocolate chip

small platter can hold approx. 18 pastries

serves 9-12

large platter can hold approx. 36 pastries 

serves 18-24

Lox Bagel Platter

bagels cut in halves w. smoked salmon, cream cheese, red onions, capers, tomato, lemon

small platter fits 6 full bagels 

large platter serves fits 12 full bagels 

Fruit Platter

berries, cantaloupe, grapes, honeydew, pineapple, watermelon

small platter serves approx. 12 

large platter serves approx. 20-30

Quiche

6" $12.95, 9" $24.95

your choice of filling

  • veggies: asparagus, broccoli, caramelized onions, roasted red pepper, spinach, tomato
  • cheeses: american, cheddar, garlic herb, pepper jack, provolone, swiss
  • meats: bacon, ham, sausage

Bagel Platter

bagels cut in halves with cream cheese

small platter fits 6 full bagels 

large platter serves fits 12 full bagels

Cookie Platter

small platter serves 9-12

large platter serves 18-24+


Deli Platters

small 12" platter $49.95, large 18" platter $99.95

Traditional Deli Platter

ham, roast beef, turkey, bologna, swiss, cheddar, american, provolone

Italian Meats Platter

salami, pepperoni, mortadella, capocollo, prosciutto, provolone, cheddar, mozzarella

Mediterranean Platter

dolmas, feta, mixed olives, cucumber, pepperoncini, pita

Antipasto Platter

salami, pepperoni, mortadella, capocollo, prosciutto, olives, pepperoncino, roasted red peppers, pickled veggies, fresh mozzarella

Veggie Platter

mixed veggies w. hummus or tzatziki 


Salads

Garden Salad

full $69.95, half $39.95

half pan serves 9-12

full pan serves 20-30

Greek Salad

full $69.95, half $39.95

half pan serves 9-12

full pan serves 20-30

Caesar Salad

full $69.95, half $39.95

half pan serves 9-12

full pan serves 20-30

Chef Salad

full $69.95, half $39.95

half pan serves 9-12

full pan serves 20-30

Deli Salads

$10.99/lb

  • Broccoli Slaw
  • Summer Veggie Pasta Salad
  • Coleslaw
  • Traditional Potato Salad

half pan serves 9-12

full pan serves 20-30

Fruit Salad

half pan serves 9-12

full pan serves 20-30


Charcuterie

Design your own

small $59.95, large $119.95

  • cheeses: brie, cheddar, parmesan, gouda, goat, feta, swiss
  • meats: salami, chorizo, capocollo, sopressata, prosciutto 
  • accoutrements: dried apricots, strawberries, grapes, olives, tapenade, crudité, fig jam, honey, nuts, dried apricots, strawberries, grapes, olives, tapenade, crudité, fig jam, honey, nuts

small platter serves 9-12

large platter serves 20-30


Sandwich Platters

Wrap Quarters

$4 per quarter

any specialty sandwich or your choice of meat + cheese

salads: tuna, chicken, egg, turkey 

wraps: white, wheat, spinach, tomato


small platter hold approx. 4-5 full wraps

large platter holds approx. 8 full wraps 

Finger Sandwiches

$4 each

salads: tuna, chicken, egg, turkey cranberry walnut


small platter hold approx. 8-10 

large platter holds approx. 20-22

Mini Lobster Rolls

market price

lobster salad, light mayo, salt + pepper on finger rolls


small platter 8-10

large platter 18-20 maximum 

Before placing your order, please inform your server if a person in your party has a food allergy. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness.

Copyright © 2026 Cotuit Fresh Market - All Rights Reserved.

  • Home
  • Menu
  • Daily Dinners
  • Catering
  • Locations

This website uses cookies.

We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.

Accept